Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports

Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports, Ratings, Reviews, Tips, and Guides in 2023

If you’re a baking enthusiast looking for the best cookie sheets to help with your delicious creations, you have come to the right place! With so many cookie sheet options on the market today, narrowing down your choices can be tough. That’s why we’re here to help.

We’ve done extensive research and compiled all of our top recommendations in one comprehensive guide: Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports. Here, you will learn about the differences between various consumer reports levels, materials used for these industry-leading products and which ones are suited for different kinds of baking needs – among other important considerations. So if you’re ready get started finding the perfect cookie sheet that suits your particular need(s), let’s get going!

Top 10 Cookie Sheets to Buy:

Below is the list of top 10 Cookie Sheets that you can have a look at and buy. Check one by one carefully before purchasing.

*Note: Score is based on our AI score (Editor’s choice and rating)

What Is Cookie Sheets?

Cookie sheets are baking trays that are designed to hold and transfer cookie dough or other baked goods as they cook.. They are often used in conjunction with a baking dish to help prevent sticking and make it easier to remove the baked good from the pan. They come in a variety of sizes, shapes, and materials; the most common are aluminum, steel, glass, silicone, and ceramic.

Some cookie sheets have cooling racks attached to them, which can be especially helpful when cooking large batches of cookies. Depending on the type of cooking task at hand- from making biscuits to roasting vegetables- you’ll want to consider the material of the cookie sheet as well its size and shape.

What Are The Different Types Of Cookie Sheets?

A cookie sheet is an essential kitchen tool and can be used for a variety of tasks, such as baking cookies or prepping other baked goods. There are many different types of cookie sheets on the market, each with its own unique features. Here are three types of cookie sheets to help you choose the best one for your needs: nonstick cookie sheets, silicone cookie sheets, and metal cookie sheets.

Nonstick Cookie Sheets: Nonstick cookie sheets are a great option if you want to avoid sticking your cookies to the pan. They’re also a popular choice for people who have trouble cleaning pans because they release food easily. Some nonstick cookie sheets come with a coating that makes it easy to remove baked goods from the sheet.

Silicone Cookie Sheets: Silicone cookie sheets are perfect if you want to make soft and delicate cookies. They’re also heat resistant, making them ideal for oven use. Some silicone cookie sheets have a removable bottom so you can easily clean them.

Metal Cookie Sheets: Metalcookie sheets are good for cookies that need stability and don’t dough well on softer surfaces like silicone ones. They’re also easier to clean because they don’t contain any chemicals or oils that can damage dishes or cookware.

Cookie Sheets With Cookie Picks: This type of cookie sheet has a grid of small holes in it, perfect for picking up cookies with your fingers. They’re often used with traditional round cookies like doughnuts or macarons, but can also be used with other shapes like stars or hearts.

Cookie Sheets With Removable Bases: These sheets have a removable base, which makes them easy to clean. They’re often used for cookies that need to be transferred to a baking sheet later on, like brownies or cakes.

It’s important to choose the right type of cookie sheet for your specific needs, so consider what you’ll be using it for and which features are most important to you.

How Does Cookie Sheets Work?

Cookie sheets are designed with a special non-stick finish to help cookies and other baked goods slide off the sheet easily. This finish is usually made of silicone or Teflon, which prevents food from sticking and makes it easier to clean up afterwards. The cookie sheets also have a slightly elevated edge that helps keep the dough from spreading out and dripping off the sides.

Cooking with cookie sheets also allows for even baking, as the heat is distributed evenly across the sheet. This makes it easier to achieve perfectly cooked cookies and other baked goods without burning them or leaving them raw in certain spots. Additionally, some cookie sheets have small ridges that can be used to create beautiful patterns on the top of the cookies.

Whether you’re baking cookies or roasted vegetables, having a good quality cookie sheet is essential for achieving delicious results. With so many different types available, it’s important to consider what kind of cooking task you’ll be using it for and select the one that best suits your needs.

Benefits Of Cookie Sheets?

Cookie sheets are an essential kitchen tool that offer many benefits. Cookie sheets can be used for a variety of tasks, such as baking cookies, brownies, and cake. Cookies that are baked on a cookie sheet tend to be softer and more tender than those that are baked in a traditional baking dish. Cookie sheets also help prevent cookies from sticking to the pan, making them easy to remove from the oven. Cookie sheets can also be used for other baking tasks, such as baking bread, cakes, and pies.

Overall, cookie sheets are great kitchen tools that can help you make delicious baked goods and other treats. They’re easy to clean, provide even baking, and are highly versatile. So if you’re looking for a convenient and durable kitchen tool, then investing in a good quality cookie sheet is definitely the way to go!

I hope this information has been helpful in understanding what a cookie sheet is and why it’s an essential kitchen tool. With the right type of cookie sheet, you can easily bake delicious treats for your family and friends. So don’t wait any longer – go ahead and invest in one today!

Happy baking! 🙂

Pros And Cons Of Cookie Sheets?


  • Easy to clean: Cookie sheets have a non-stick coating that makes them easy to clean up after use.
  • Even baking: Cookie sheets conduct heat evenly, so your cookies and other baked goods won’t be burned or undercooked in certain spots.
  • Versatile: Cookie sheets are versatile tools that can be used for a variety of tasks like roasting vegetables, prepping doughs and sauces, making candies, and baking cookies.
  • Durable: Cookie sheets are usually made of sturdy materials like steel or aluminum which makes them long-lasting kitchen tools.
  • Easy to store: Most cookie sheets can be easily folded up and stored away in a drawer or cupboard when not in use.


  • Lack of flexibility: Cookie sheets can be difficult to maneuver when transferring hot food from the oven.
  • Not dishwasher safe: Most cookie sheets are not dishwasher safe, so they must be hand-washed after each use.
  • Poor heat retention: Cookie sheets do not retain heat as well as other types of baking tools, so cookies may cool more quickly.
  • Expensive: Good quality cookie sheets can be quite expensive.

Overall, while there are some drawbacks to using cookie sheets, they offer many benefits that make them a great kitchen tool.

Factors To Consider Before Buying Cookie Sheets?

When selecting a cookie sheet, there are several important factors to consider.

-Size: The size of the cookie sheet you choose should depend on the amount of food you plan to bake.

-Material: Cookie sheets come in a variety of materials such as aluminum, steel, silicone, and ceramic. Consider which material is best suited for your baking needs before making a purchase.

-Nonstick Coating: If you want easy removal of baked goods, then make sure to choose a cookie sheet with a non-stick coating.

-Design: Some cookie sheets feature decorative designs or patterns on the top, which can add an extra touch of flair to your baking tasks.

-Price: Be sure to compare different brands and prices before buying, as good quality cookie sheets can be quite expensive.

Warranty: Look for a cookie sheet that comes with a warranty, as this will help protect your investment in case of any defects or damages.

By taking the time to consider these factors, you can ensure that you choose a cookie sheet that bes suits your baking needs.

How To Use Cookie Sheets?

Using a cookie sheet is easy and straightforward.

-Preheat oven: Begin by preheating your oven to the desired temperature.

-Gather ingredients: Gather all necessary ingredients and tools, such as mixing bowls, spoons, spatulas, etc.

-Line sheet with parchment paper: Place a piece of parchment paper on top of the cookie sheet. This will provide a nonstick surface and make cleanup much easier.

-Mix ingredients: Follow your recipe instructions to mix together all ingredients until they are thoroughly combined.

-Form dough into shapes: Form the dough into desired shapes, such as circles or squares, and place them onto the parchment paper.

-Bake: Place the cookie sheet into the preheated oven and bake according to recipe instructions.

-Cool: Remove the cookie sheet from the oven and let it cool before removing the cookies or other baked goods.

By following these steps, you can easily use a cookie sheet to make delicious treats for your family and friends. Enjoy!

Common Mistakes When Using Cookie Sheets?

Even though using a cookie sheet is easy, there are a few common mistakes that can be made.

-Not preheating the oven: Before baking anything in the oven, make sure to preheat it first. Not doing so could cause the food to burn or not bake evenly.

-Using too much butter or oil: When making cookies or other baked goods, be mindful of how much butter or oil you use. Too much can cause the dough to spread too thinly and result in a greasy mess.

-Using the wrong cookie sheet: Before baking, make sure to use a cookie sheet that is suitable for your recipe. Using the wrong material or size may result in uneven baking or burnt food.

-Not using parchment paper: Parchment paper helps to provide a nonstick surface for cookies and other baked goods, so make sure to use it when necessary.

-Not cooling cookies: It’s important to let cookies cool before removing them from the cookie sheet. Otherwise, they may break apart or stick to the pan.

By avoiding these common mistakes, you can ensure that your baking projects turn out perfectly every time!

How To Clean Cookie Sheets?

Cleaning cookie sheets is relatively easy.

-Scrape off excess food: Start by scraping off any excess food or crumbs from the cookie sheet.

-Wash with dish soap and warm water: Next, fill the sink with warm water and a few drops of dish soap. Submerge the cookie sheet in the water and use a sponge to scrub off any dirt or grime.

-Rinse with cold water: When finished cleaning, rinse the cookie sheet with cold water.

-Dry and store: Dry off the cookie sheet with a cloth or paper towel and then store in a cool dry place.

By following these steps, you can ensure that your cookie sheets stay in good condition and last for years to come.


What kind of cookie sheets are best for cookies?

Nonstick cookie sheets are best for baking cookies, as they provide a nonstick surface and evenly distribute heat.

What is the best way to store cookie sheets?

The best way to store cookie sheets is in a cool, dry place away from direct sunlight. This will help ensure that your cookie sheets stay in good condition and last longer.

What temperature can cookie sheets withstand?

Most cookie sheets can withstand temperatures up to 450°F. However, it’s always best to check the manufacturer’s instructions before using your cookie sheet in high heat.

How do I clean a burnt cookie sheet?

If your cookie sheet is heavily stained or has burned-on food, you may need to use more abrasive cleaning methods. Start by sprinkling baking soda over the burnt area and then scrub with a stiff brush or steel wool. Rinse with water and repeat as necessary until the stains are gone.

Can I use a cookie sheet for other things besides baking?

Yes! Cookie sheets can also be used to roast vegetables, bake fish, reheat pizza, and even make grilled cheese sandwiches. Be sure to check the manufacturer’s instructions before using your cookie sheet for anything other than baking.

Can you bake cookies straight on the sheet?

Yes, you can bake cookies directly on the sheet. However, it’s best to line the sheet with parchment paper or a silicone baking mat for easy cleanup and prevention of sticking.

Do you need to oil baking sheet?

No, you do not need to oil the baking sheet. However, it can be helpful if you’re using a nonstick cookie sheet and want to ensure that nothing sticks. In this case, you can lightly brush the sheet with vegetable or olive oil before baking.

Can I use a cookie sheet in an air fryer?

No, you should not use a cookie sheet in an air fryer. The air fryer’s high heat can cause the sheet to warp or even catch fire. Use only metal baskets and racks specifically designed for air fryers.

Can I stack cookie sheets?

Yes, you can stack cookie sheets together for storage. However, be sure to use only cookie sheets of the same size and material. This will help to ensure that the sheets don’t warp or bend when stacked.

Are baking sheets reusable?

Yes, baking sheets are usually reusable. However, depending on how often you use them and what type of food you’re cooking with them, they may need to be replaced sooner than expected. If your baking sheets have started to show signs of wear or discoloration, it may be time to replace them.

Can I bake cookies on aluminum foil?

Yes, you can bake cookies on aluminum foil. Just be sure to use heavy-duty foil, as it is thicker and will better withstand the heat of the oven. It is also important to lightly grease the foil before baking cookies so they don’t stick.

How often should you replace baking sheets?

It’s important to inspect your baking sheets regularly for signs of wear and tear. If you notice any discoloration, rust spots, or warping, it’s time to replace them. Generally speaking, it is recommended that baking sheets be replaced every 1-2 years.


We have explored the best cookie sheets according to Consumer Reports to help you decide which is the best option for your baking needs. After going through our review, you should have a better idea of what features to look for and what kind of budget you need in order to achieve optimal results. We discussed top products from both big-name manufacturers as well as those from lesser-known companies.

Ultimately, choosing the best cookie sheet will depend on longevity, ease of use and cleaning, and how each type handles cookies during their baking process. With this information in hand, feel confident that you’re properly equipped to choose a product that fits your culinary needs. Spend some time comparison shopping and reading reviews before deciding which cookie sheet is best for your recipe! For more detailed reviews on Best Cookie Sheets Consumer Reports, don’t hesitate to visit us again soon!

Leave a Comment